The Trump administration had promised a bombshell. People, lots of whom had spent years questioning over the unknowns within the Jeffrey Epstein case, would lastly get their arms on the key information that may clarify all of it. What actually occurred when the accused intercourse trafficker died in jail again in 2019? And who was on his “consumer checklist”—a rumored assortment of well-known and highly effective individuals who participated in Epstein’s crimes?
In a September 2024 interview on the Lex Fridman Podcast, Donald Trump urged that he would launch the checklist if reelected. “Yeah, I’d be inclined to do the Epstein; I’d don’t have any downside with it,” Trump mentioned. He indulged hypothesis about Epstein after his reelection as properly. In February, the White Home hosted a set of MAGA-world influencers and gave them binders stuffed with closely redacted Epstein-related paperwork labeled Part 1, suggesting extra to return.
The Trump administration has been unusually targeted on messaging about such data, making a present of pulling the curtain again on supposed secrets and techniques. Trump equally promoted the discharge of additional paperwork associated to the John F. Kennedy assassination, together with information on the killings of Martin Luther King Jr. and Senator Robert F. Kennedy. In an govt order signed this January, the administration framed these efforts as “PROVIDING AMERICANS THE TRUTH.” At an April listening to on these information, Nancy Mace, a Trump ally and consultant from South Carolina, introduced up the so-called Epstein checklist. In a meandering assertion, she spoke about her need to see paperwork concerning Epstein, in addition to Hunter Biden’s laptop computer and the origins of the coronavirus. All have been recurring web fascinations amongst Trump’s supporters. “Sunshine actually is one of the best medication,” Mace argued.
A private want checklist of coveted secrets and techniques just isn’t precisely the identical factor as a principled name for presidency transparency. However the two are straightforward to conflate and may have some incidental overlap, which might be politically helpful. The promise of beforehand withheld revelations has allowed Trump to border himself as an outsider combating on behalf of voters who’ve been saved at the hours of darkness by the institution. The catch is that after he was again in workplace, he was put within the awkward place of getting to ship.
On Monday, the FBI launched a memo saying that it had reviewed all of its information on Epstein and that it doesn’t plan to launch extra in any case; there will likely be no Part 2. In keeping with the FBI, solely a “fraction” of the remaining materials would have grow to be public if Epstein had lived to go to trial, as a result of it contains “a big quantity” of unlawful content material involving underaged victims of sexual abuse—in different phrases, materials that can’t be launched to the general public. The memo additionally famous, in a single breezy paragraph, that the bureau’s evaluate had uncovered neither a consumer checklist nor proof “that Epstein blackmailed outstanding people as a part of his actions.” There will likely be no new investigation in opposition to “uncharged third events,” the memo mentioned. This has come as a shock to a bunch of people that have lengthy purchased into the concept Trump would in the future unmask an evil ring of Democrats and liberal-coded celebrities.
Anna Paulina Luna, a consultant from Florida and the chair of the Process Power on the Declassification of Federal Secrets and techniques, which facilitated the latest doc releases concerning JFK, instructed me that she will likely be asking the Division of Justice to authorize the discharge of extra Epstein particulars anyway. “I feel the American individuals nonetheless have questions and there may be stuff that they will launch,” she mentioned. She didn’t remark particularly on the existence of a consumer checklist and mentioned she didn’t but know precisely what sort of paperwork the FBI would possibly nonetheless have (clarifying that she agreed that the bureau shouldn’t launch any personal particulars about victims or child-sexual-abuse materials).
Within the meantime, the about-face on the Epstein information is splintering MAGA world, and plenty of Trump allies are feeling betrayed and unmoored. “Nobody believes there may be not a consumer checklist,” wrote Marjorie Taylor Greene, the consultant from Georgia who has avidly promoted QAnon conspiracy theories. “This can be a shameful coverup to guard probably the most heinous elites,” one of many influencers who went to the White Home in February, Rogan O’Handley (who goes by “DC Draino”), instructed his greater than 2 million X followers on Monday. Longtime Trump loyalists, together with the conspiracy theorist Alex Jones, began sharing a meme on Monday that depicted a bunch of cartoon lizard individuals laughing about having pulled one over on the unsuspecting public but once more. Unusual—some readers could also be sufficiently old to recollect when it was Hillary Clinton and different Democrats who have been the shadowy reptilian elite, secretly shedding their human pores and skin each time out of public sight.
Important ire has been directed at Lawyer Normal Pam Bondi, who responded to a query a few consumer checklist in February by saying it was “sitting on my desk proper now to evaluate.” Throughout a press convention on Monday afternoon, White Home Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt mentioned that Bondi had truly been referring to “the whole lot of all of the paperwork” on Epstein and to not a selected doc. Shortly thereafter, the net crowd started questioning why Leavitt had not been sporting her traditional cross necklace on the briefing—an indication, maybe, that she was mendacity and didn’t need to accomplish that in entrance of God (to paraphrase the posts, which have been principally ruder than that). After I requested Luna if Trump’s supporters had a proper to really feel pissed off, she deflected the query, saying, “I can’t converse for individuals on the web or the president. What I can say is President Trump is on the cusp of negotiating a everlasting cease-fire with Israel and Hamas in Gaza. That is overshadowing the quantity of success the administration has had in that sense.”
But that is undeniably a turning level for the extremely on-line amongst Trump’s base. The story of the consumer checklist had successfully morphed right into a extra palatable and believable model of the QAnon conspiracy concept. As does QAnon, it includes a secret ring of evildoers, although it doesn’t have sure ostentatious parts of that conspiracy (no harvesting blood). However each theories encourage individuals to disbelieve every thing the federal government tells them. Till now, Trump and his appointees have been positioned as exceptions to that rule—the deal was that in the event that they bought again into energy, they’d reveal all.
Mark Fenster, a professor on the College of Florida’s regulation faculty who has written about authorities transparency and conspiracy theories, noticed to me that, together with his administrative appointments, Trump had made implicit guarantees to his supporters. “He particularly nominated individuals for high-level positions who’ve been engaged in conspiracy theories for the previous five-plus years,” Fenster identified. As an illustration, FBI Director Kash Patel and Deputy Director Dan Bongino have supplied wild theories concerning the Epstein case up to now—Patel as soon as urged that the FBI could also be protecting up proof to guard unnamed elites, whereas Bongino mentioned he’d heard a rumor that Epstein was a overseas intelligence agent.
Now the conspiracy is mutating once more to suit the administration’s reversal. “To listen to Pam Bondi and to listen to Kash Patel and Don Bongino saying there isn’t any checklist—you’re going to say, ‘Nicely, they should be a part of the conspiracy too,’” Fenster urged, which is definitely one avenue individuals have gone down. As a result of the FBI’s memo coincided roughly with a diplomatic go to of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to the White Home, others have began suggesting that Epstein was secretly a Mossad agent (a declare usually expressed with anti-Semitic rhetoric). Alex Jones, who was initially livid concerning the FBI memo, has since speculated that Trump has truly taken “management” of the alleged checklist and is utilizing it to blackmail the “deep state” behind the scenes.
In fact, some have began selecting aside the FBI memo itself. It concluded with hyperlinks to 2 movies of a hallway within the Metropolitan Correctional Heart the place Epstein had been held, exhibiting that no one went into his cell the night time of his loss of life. Viewers rapidly seen that the clock within the nook of the video skips from 11:59:00 to 12:00:00, which urged to them {that a} minute of footage was lacking.
On Tuesday afternoon, when a reporter tried to ask Bondi concerning the foreign-intelligence concept and the video-clock concern, Trump lower in. “Are you continue to speaking about Jeffrey Epstein?” he requested incredulously. “This man’s been talked about for years. You’re asking—we’ve got Texas, we’ve got this, we’ve got all the issues, and are individuals nonetheless speaking about this man, this creep? That’s unbelievable.” Bondi mentioned she didn’t thoughts answering the query, however Trump went on. “I can’t consider you’re asking a query on Epstein at a time like this the place we’re having a few of the biggest success and likewise tragedy with what occurred in Texas,” he mentioned, referring to the flooding that has killed not less than 120 individuals.
Finally, he waved for Bondi to go forward. She instructed the reporter she had no data of Epstein being an agent, then defined that the video hadn’t been doctored and that the clocks on the outdated cameras within the Metropolitan Correctional Heart all the time soar forward as they strategy midnight. From what I noticed, hardly anybody on-line was shopping for this rationalization, which comes as no shock. Trump and his administration invited conspiracy theories into the White Home. Now they’re going to have a tough time getting them out.
