Within the lead-up to final evening’s Emmy Awards, the host, Nate Bargatze, defined that he needed to maintain the night as tightly-run as attainable, in order that the ceremony wouldn’t exceed its three-hour timeslot. To implement order, he supposed to depend on a single bit all through the present: For each second a winner went over their allotted time for giving an acceptance speech, he’d take $1,000 away from a deliberate $100,000 donation to the Boys & Ladies Golf equipment of America. For each second somebody saved, he’d add $1,000 again to the pot. This fashion, the Emmys would focus solely on celebrating one of the best of TV, and nothing else. “I want this to be a enjoyable evening,” he instructed Selection. “There’s sufficient of the opposite stuff happening.”

This most likely appeared like a good suggestion on paper: Awards reveals notoriously run lengthy, and acceptance speeches are likely to cowl related floor; if something, Bargatze reasoned, “all evening we will likely be speaking concerning the Boys & Ladies Membership.” However in follow, the technique resulted in audio system speeding via their thank-yous, apologizing to the kids representing the group on stage, and a considerably scripted broadcast. In attempting to reduce the speeches, the Emmys underlined simply how crucial they’re to the present’s pageantry.

Each ceremony should overcome the inherently repetitive nature of its format. Stars swan onto a stage to current an award; an inventory of nominees performs; a winner is introduced; a speech is given. Lather, rinse, repeat. Other than musical performances or sudden pairings of presenters, the night’s emcee performs essentially the most essential function in breaking apart the monotony: She or he would possibly become an array of various telegenic outfits, act in a sequence of skits, and even sing a solo earlier than the group. However on Sunday evening, Bargatze didn’t reveal any hidden skills. As an alternative, he introduced one huge joke—and, hammered time and again throughout three hours, it went from cute to awkward.

The bit was virtually sufficient to sap the Emmys solely of the vitality that comes when an sudden winner will get to react, together with the viewers, to their shock victory. And this yr, it was arduous to inform who would possibly come out on high in lots of classes. The Studio, producing buzz among the many comedy classes, was up towards Emmy heavyweights equivalent to Hacks and The Bear. The Pitt, in the meantime, was going through off a sterling second season of Severance. That meant a number of surprises all through the evening: Andor, neglected in most of the primetime Emmys classes, received for Excellent Writing For a Drama Collection. Gradual Horses received solely its second Emmy ever, for Excellent Directing For a Drama Collection. Jeff Hiller received Excellent Supporting Actor in a Comedy Collection for his work on the underseen comedy Any person Someplace, and his heartfelt speech, which referred to as for compassion and empathy, was a famous spotlight.

Learn: Sitting with an offended teen, for longer than you may want

However many times, Bargatze targeted much less on those that had received than on the stakes of working additional time. After Andor’s win, he thanked Gilroy for “serving to me out” by maintaining the speech brief. After Hiller left the stage, he identified how a lot cash had already been deducted from the pot. Every time, the bit undermined the feelings of the speeches, whereas making the Boys & Ladies Membership come off extra as a punchline than a worthy trigger.

As an alternative, as winners sped via their speeches, the night ended up dedicating most of its airtime to what often makes awards reveals really feel extra-lethargic: the scripted, barely rehearsed speeches that presenters give earlier than every award. These went lengthy, too, with no monetary penalty. (Not each change went off as deliberate, both: Witness the painfully awkward introduction to the Excellent Directing For a Restricted or Anthology Collection or Film class, when the actor-director Elizabeth Banks highlighted the class’s 5 feminine nominees, just for the sixth and solely male director to win as a substitute.) And in moments when a winner did say what was on their thoughts, the Boys & Ladies Membership bit overwhelmed them. Take Hannah Einbinder, one other shock winner who took house her first trophy in Excellent Supporting Actress In a Comedy for Hacks. She ended her rushed speech with a passionate message—“fuck ICE, and free Palestine”—just for a graphic displaying how a lot cash was being deducted to indicate up onscreen, since she went a number of seconds lengthy.

The reality is, there may be not often a Merritt Wever or an Adrien Brody in awards speeches—excessive instances of brevity or verbosity that stun each these within the room and at house. Because the evening progressed, winners appeared to know that they didn’t need to succumb to Bargatze’s gag, and will ramble just a bit. Stephen Colbert, accepting The Late Present’s first Emmy for Excellent Discuss Collection, mirrored on the finish of his present and the state of American politics. “I spotted that in some methods we had been doing a late-night comedy present about loss, and that’s associated to like as a result of typically you solely really understand how a lot you like one thing once you get a way that you just is perhaps dropping it,” he mentioned, earlier than including, “My buddies, I’ve by no means cherished my nation extra desperately.”

Moments of sincerity like these got here late, and barely, in the course of the Emmys. Bargatze didn’t know what to do with these, both—he later referred to as consideration to the size of Colbert’s speech, not its substance. In the long run, there was one remaining, uninteresting twist: Bargatze, together with CBS, which aired the ceremony, can be donating a complete of $350,000 to the Boys & Ladies Membership anyway. The runtime of the speeches hadn’t actually mattered—and regardless of Bargatze’s said intentions, the awards weren’t all that enjoyable, both.